Navy Times editor’s note: With ongoing reports about panic buyers stripping stores bare of cleaning products and toilet paper, some of you might be tempted to make your own hand sanitizer. But before you embark on DIY home medical supplies, read biologist Jeffery Gardner explain why that’s probably not a good idea. And stop hoarding toilet paper.
1. Why is alcohol the main ingredient in most hand sanitizers?
Alcohol is effective at killing different types of microbes, including both viruses and bacteria, because it unfolds and inactivates their proteins. This process, which is called denaturation, will cripple and often kill the microbe because its proteins will unfold and stick together.
Heat can also denature some proteins – for example, when you cook an egg, the solidified egg whites are denatured proteins.
2. Alcohol doesn’t kill some microbes very well - why not?
There are different types of bacteria and viruses, and some types are more easily killed by alcohol. For example, E. coli bacteria, which can cause foodborne illness and other infections, are very effectively killed by alcohol at concentrations over 60 percent.
Differences in the outside surface of various bacteria make alcohol sanitization more effective against some of them than others.
Similarly, some viruses have an outer wrapping, which is called an envelope, while others are non-enveloped. Alcohol is effective at killing enveloped viruses, including the coronavirus, but is less effective at killing non-enveloped viruses.
Whether you are trying to kill bacteria or viruses, many research studies have found that an alcohol concentration of 60 percent or greater is needed to be effective.
3. If 60 percent alcohol is good, is 100 percent better?
Protein denaturation actually works faster when a small amount of water is mixed with the alcohol. And pure alcohol would evaporate too quickly to effectively kill bacteria or viruses on your skin, especially during winter when the air is less humid.
Using 100 percent alcohol also would dry your skin out very quickly and cause it to become irritated. That might cause you to not sanitize your hands as frequently as needed. This is why most hand sanitizers contain emollients, which are mixtures that help soften and moisturize your skin.
4. Are homemade hand sanitizers a good idea?
In my view, no. You may see do-it-yourself formulas online, including some that use vodka. However, vodka is typically 80 proof, which means it’s only 40 percent alcohol. That’s not high enough to effectively kill microbes.
The rubbing alcohol you have in your bathroom for cuts and scrapes might seem like a good alternative, but if you are already near a sink, the best choice is to wash your hands with soap and hot water.
5. Does hand sanitizer expire?
Most commercial hand sanitizers are effective for a couple of years when they are stored properly, and are marked with expiration dates. One thing to keep in mind is that alcohol is volatile, which means that over time the alcohol will slowly evaporate and the sanitizer will lose its ability to effectively kill viruses and bacteria.
However, with hand sanitizer in such high demand now, you’re unlikely to buy one that is expired.
Dr. Jeffrey Gardner is an associate professor in Biology at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County. The Gardner Lab there is focused on understanding the metabolism and physiology of bacteria, specifically how they sense their environment and obtain energy. The lab combines the fields of transcriptomics, bacterial genetics and biochemistry.